3

The tag sounds vague and judgemental. What exactly about what happened is "bad"? Shouldn't a tag for that be used instead (like , in use on at least one of these questions)? In any difference of opinion between an unhappy user and a moderator, one side of that is going to want to apply the word "bad"; that doesn't make it so.

What does this tag add? If the answer is "nothing", what should we do with the questions so tagged?

1

I have just taken care of all questions .

We're left with three questions that relate to incorrect actions taken by a moderator, one of which also held the tag, which seems more descriptive for this issue. However, I think we can find a better tag for that, too, and I'd like to see a suggestion in that respect.

2

I think we should remove the tag. Here are the questions currently tagged this way and proposed tagging changes.

I am being blamed for an incorrect moderator action I didn't take. What should be done? (also bears the problematic "moderator-relationship" tag, which I'm ignoring for now): this is about , and maybe .

How should I deal with a moderator who shows favoritism?: already tagged , which is sufficient.

How can a site be rescued after an exodus of moderators?: I see we have a tag (which I'm uncertain about, but if we have it, it seems to apply). This is also about .

Moderator bans user in the course of an on-topic argument: and seem to cover this fine. (I have an edit pending here, actually, made before I thought about the larger problem with this tag.)

How do you handle community backlash over an incorrect action taken by a moderator?: already tagged and ; that seems sufficient. Also, as described, this question isn't so much about bad moderation as erroneous moderation; while errors are bad, "bad" here seems to be more about intent/malice.

How should we deal with moderators who are making bad calls?: sounds like to me. And if we don't already have a tag for moderator oversight (covering, e.g., issues involving site owners and other people above the moderators), maybe we need one.

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .